Makalaurë Kanafinwë

I have heard some who say that, but if Men return they do not do so in the same form as they did before - for us, Rebirth is quite literally that. You walk from the Halls in the body that you died in, albeit healed of its hurts. If Men are indeed reborn... I do not know if all or only some. I know that Luthien chose mortality, she who was the fairest of all the Eruhin to ever live, and that she and her husband passed beyond the walls never to return, but if others might... I do not know.